Hitmetrix - User behavior analytics & recording

The Impact of “Defect” Ads on Amazon

Defect Ads
Defect Ads

Amazon’s dominance in online retail has grown stronger in recent years. Advertising practices have come under scrutiny as the company has expanded. Allegations that Amazon encouraged “defect” ads on its platform to increase advertising revenue have recently been declassified as part of the FTC’s antitrust complaint against the company. Irrelevant advertisements not only detract from the user experience, but also encourage people to buy more expensive items. This information provides context for one of Amazon’s fastest-growing business lines—ad sales.

The Growth and Influence of Retail-Based Media

Amazon’s success in the retail media space has set the standard for the industry. One digital advertising channel that has grown rapidly since the pandemic’s inception is retail media, which uses consumer data to better target online advertising campaigns for brands. Retail media aspires to improve the efficiency of marketing for both businesses and consumers by better aligning messages with the point of purchase via first-party data. However, recent claims against Amazon suggest that the company may have compromised the customer experience in its pursuit of faster growth.

Forrester Research’s senior performance marketing analyst Nikhil Lai thinks Amazon isn’t alone in putting profit before customer satisfaction. He argues that a focus on profit maximization at retail media networks has hurt the quality of service provided to customers. This casts doubt on the retail media industry’s overall efficacy and openness.

Amazon’s “Defect” Ads and Their Supposed Role in the Company’s Poor Performance

Amazon founder and former CEO Jeff Bezos is accused of being the driving force behind the decision to “[a]ccept more defects” in the FTC’s complaint. Bezos thought this would allow him to make more money off of advertisements. The underlying theory was that deprecating the ad experience would not necessarily result in a loss of revenue. In Q3, Amazon’s ad sales reached $12 billion, up 26% year-over-year, proving the validity of this hypothesis. UnBoxed, the company’s annual showcase for advertisers, reflects the success and significance of this sector.

Amazon’s “cost of defect” in its ad auction system was a response to the prevalence of spammy ads on the marketplace. This was an effort to raise income by fining companies whose advertisements fell short of expectations. However, there was little tangible result from all the talk of preserving the customer experience. An unnamed Amazon executive was quoted in the FTC complaint as saying that a desire to maximize profit had become “the law” at the company.

Consumer and Merchant Consequences

Consumers and vendors alike may feel the effects of these allegations against Amazon. Users’ search experiences are negatively impacted by “defect” ads, and they are also nudged toward more expensive options. Consumers’ trust and happiness can be damaged when ads are manipulated in this way.

Sellers may see a drop in traffic and revenue if monetization is prioritized over the customer experience, as has been suggested. It is more challenging for vendors to reach their intended audience and generate conversions if ads are not pertinent to consumers’ queries. This begs the question of whether or not sellers are actually benefiting from advertising on the Amazon platform.

The Reaction of Amazon and How Effective Their Ads Are

Amazon has denied the FTC complaint’s claims in the strongest possible terms. Amazon spokesman Tim Doyle called the claim that the company’s leadership had told employees to accept more advertising flaws “grossly misleading and taken out of context.” He cites Kantar research that found most consumers view Amazon advertising as relevant and useful. Concerns have been raised about the efficacy and openness of Amazon’s advertising due to the apparent gap between consumer perception and the allegations made in the complaint.

Amazon’s advertising business has been booming despite the negative press. The company’s decision to include advertising results in its earnings announcements at the start of 2022 is indicative of the growing importance of its advertising business. As a result of the significance of ad revenue in the retail industry, other retail media network owners like Walmart have followed suit.

The Urgent Need for Retail Media Transparency and Standardization

Concerns about privacy and openness have surfaced in response to the expansion of retail media. These problems have plagued the digital marketing landscape for a long time, mainly because of the consolidation of power by companies like Google and Facebook. As the number of retail media networks grows, there is pressure for widespread adoption of industry standards to address inevitable complications that will arise.

However, the absence of Amazon’s involvement could be a barrier to standardization. The company has enormous sway over the development of retail media thanks to its dominant position in online commerce. Achieving transparency and standardization may prove difficult without Amazon’s active involvement in shaping industry standards.

See first source: Marketing Dive


1. What recent allegations have been made against Amazon regarding its advertising practices?

Recent allegations suggest that Amazon encouraged “defect” ads on its platform to boost advertising revenue, as revealed in the FTC’s antitrust complaint against the company.

2. How do irrelevant advertisements affect users and Amazon’s business?

Irrelevant ads detract from the user experience and can lead people to buy more expensive items, impacting consumer trust and satisfaction.

3. What is retail media, and why has it gained importance during the pandemic?

Retail media uses consumer data to target online advertising campaigns effectively. It has grown rapidly, aiming to improve marketing efficiency for businesses and consumers by aligning messages with the point of purchase.

4. Are there concerns about the quality of service in the retail media industry?

Yes, some experts, like Nikhil Lai from Forrester Research, believe that a focus on profit maximization at retail media networks may have compromised service quality.

5. What role did Jeff Bezos play in Amazon’s ad strategy?

Jeff Bezos is accused of driving the decision to “[a]ccept more defects” in ads to increase ad revenue. This approach has been successful, with Amazon’s ad sales reaching $12 billion in Q3.

6. What are the consequences for consumers and sellers due to these allegations against Amazon?

Consumers experience negatively impacted search results and are nudged toward more expensive options. Sellers may see reduced traffic and revenue if monetization is prioritized over the customer experience.

7. How has Amazon reacted to the FTC complaint’s claims?

Amazon has strongly denied the claims and cites Kantar research showing that most consumers view Amazon advertising as relevant and useful.

8. How has Amazon’s advertising business performed despite negative press?

Amazon’s advertising business has been thriving, as indicated by its inclusion of advertising results in earnings announcements. Other retail media network owners, like Walmart, have also recognized the importance of ad revenue.

9. What issues have arisen regarding retail media transparency and standardization?

Concerns about privacy and transparency have emerged as retail media has expanded. Achieving transparency and standardization in the industry may be challenging without Amazon’s active involvement due to its significant influence in online commerce.

10. Why is Amazon’s involvement crucial for industry standardization in retail media?

Amazon’s dominant position in online commerce gives it significant sway in the development of retail media. Without its active involvement, achieving industry-wide transparency and standardization may be more difficult.

Featured Image Credit: Photo by ANIRUDH; Unsplash – Thank you!

Related Posts
E-Book Popup

Unlock the Secrets of Digital Marketing in 2024!

Subscribe to our newsletter and get your FREE copy of “The Ultimate Guide to Digital Marketing Trends in 2024"